Comparing HSAs, HRAs and FSAs: Which Approach Is Best?

Employers are increasingly looking to consumer driven health plans to help soften the blow of continually rising health care costs. Depending on the model, consumer driven health plans typically include health reimbursement arrangements (HRAs), flexible spending accounts (FSAs) or health savings accounts (HSAs).
Consumer driven health plans generally increase employees’ stake in their own health care costs. In most cases, a consumer driven health plan covers a wide range of medical expenses, but also includes more cost-sharing for participants (for example, higher deductibles). Some plans incorporate an HRA, health FSA or HSA to help employees pay for their out-of-pocket medical expenses on a tax-free basis. This article provides some basic information about the similarities and differences between HRAs, FSAs and HSAs.


HSAs

Due to their tax-favored status, HSAs have strict rules regarding eligibility and contributions. In order to make or receive HSA contributions, individuals must meet the following qualifications:

  • Be covered by a high deductible health plan (HDHP)
  • Not have any other health coverage (with some exceptions)
  • Not be claimed as a dependent on another person’s tax return
  • Not be covered by Medicare

The employer and employee can contribute to the HSA in the same year, subject to annual limits. Employers may allow employees to make pre-tax salary reduction contributions to fund their HSAs. Individuals may roll over unspent funds in the HSA from year to year. Since the HSA is a tax-exempt account owned by the employee, he or she may keep the account upon termination of employment or retirement.


Health FSAs

Health FSAs provide a means for employees to reduce their income tax liability through salary reduction. Employees can contribute a portion of their own salary to an account designated to pay for health care expenses. These pre-tax contributions are exempt from income and payroll taxes. The Affordable Care Act (ACA) limits employee’s pre-tax contributions to their health FSAs to $3,200 (adjusted for inflation for future plan years).

There are some strict design requirements for health FSAs that have negatively impacted their popularity. While any individual who satisfies the HSA eligibility criteria can make HSA contributions, only employees can participate in a health FSA. This means that, while self-employed individuals can establish health FSAs for their employees, they cannot set up their own accounts.

In addition, FSAs have a “use-it-or-lose-it” provision. In general, employees are required to elect a specific amount of salary reduction at the beginning of the year, and then must use every dollar in the account by the end of that year. Because annual medical expenses are hard to predict, employees often overfund the accounts and then spend unnecessarily at the end of the year to avoid forfeiting the money in their accounts.

To help avoid this problem, the IRS allows health FSAs to incorporate either a grace period or carry-over feature. Health FSAs with a grace period allow participants to access unused amounts remaining in an FSA at the end of the plan year to pay for expenses incurred during a grace period of up to two and a half months after the end of the plan year. Alternatively, health FSAs may allow participants to carry over up to $640* of unused funds remaining at the end of a plan year to be used for qualified medical expenses incurred during the following plan year.

Health FSAs are also subject to a uniform coverage rule, which requires the health FSA to operate like an insurance plan, with the employer assuming the risk of loss. Under this rule, an employee’s maximum reimbursement amount for a year must be available at any time during the coverage period, even if a reimbursement would exceed the year-to-date contributions to the employee’s FSA.

Health FSAs are group health plans that are subject to laws such as the ACA, the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) and the Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act (COBRA).


HRAs

HRAs allow employees to use employer contributions to pay for (or reimburse) eligible medical care expenses. HRAs can only be funded with employer money; employees cannot make contributions to their HRAs. Unlike health FSAs, unused HRA balances may accumulate from year to year.

There is no specified cap on the amount an employer is allowed to contribute to an HRA. Also, an HRA is not subject to the uniform coverage rule that applies to health FSAs. However, like health FSAs, only employees can participate in an HRA, which means that self-employed individuals cannot participate in an HRA on a tax-favored basis.

Like health FSAs, HRAs are group health plans that are subject to laws such as HIPAA and COBRA. Under the ACA, most HRAs must be “integrated” with another group health plan to satisfy certain market reforms. However, there are exceptions to this requirement for certain types of HRA designs, including retiree-only HRAs.


Deciding on the Right Approach

Introducing consumerism into your health plan requires an evaluation of the benefits and disadvantages of HSAs, FSAs and HRAs. No one solution is right for every employer. If your organization is considering implementing a consumer driven health plan, your Consociate Health representative can help you decide which plan is best for you.

HSA HRA FSA
Type of account Health Savings Account Health Reimbursement Arrangement* Health Flexible Spending Account
Who owns the account? Individual/employee Employer Employer
Who may fund the account? Anyone can make contributions to an individual’s HSA, including employer and/or employee. Employer Employer and/or employee
What plans must be offered with the account? A high deductible health plan (HDHP) that satisfies minimum annual deductible and maximum annual out- of-pocket expense requirements. An employer must offer a health plan and the HRA must be considered integrated with group health plan coverage. Most Health FSAs must qualify as excepted benefits to satisfy ACA reforms. To qualify as an excepted benefit, the FSA must meet a maximum benefit requirement and other group health plan coverage must be offered by the employer.
Is there an annual contribution limit? $3,850 Ind. $7,750 Family (2023) $4,150 Ind. $8,300 Family (2024) Catch-up contributions: $1,000/year– age 55 by end of tax year No, there is no IRS prescribed limit For plan years beginning in 2023, employees may not elect to contribute more than $3,050. The limit is $3,200 in 2024.
Can unused funds be rolled over from year to year? Yes Yes No, with two exceptions. A health FSA may include a grace period of 2-1/2 months after end of plan year or it may allow employees to carry over up to $640 (as adjusted for inflation) in unused funds into the next plan year.
What expenses are eligible for reimbursement? Section 213(d) medical expenses, including: -COBRA premiums -QLTC premiums -Health premiums while receiving unemployment benefits -If Medicare eligible due to age, health insurance premiums except medical supplement policies Section 213(d) medical expenses Effective for 2014 plan years, cannot reimburse health insurance premiums for individual coverage Employer can define “eligible medical expenses” Section 213(d) medical expenses for insurance premiums are not reimbursable Employer can define “eligible medical expenses”
Must claims be substantiated? No Yes Yes
May the account reimburse non- medical expenses? Yes, but taxed as income and 20% penalty (no penalty if distributed after death, disability, or age 65) No No
Does the uniform coverage rule apply? No No Yes

*For purposes of this comparison chart, an HRA refers to a traditional HRA that is properly integrated with a group health plan. It does not include retiree-only HRAs, qualified small employer HRAs, individual coverage HRAs or excepted benefit HRAs.


This Benefits Insights is not intended to be exhaustive nor should any discussion or opinions be construed as professional advice. © 2015, 2017-2023 Zywave, Inc. All rights reserved.

Share this post:


Skip to content

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. Privacy Policy

The cookie settings on this website are set to "allow cookies" to give you the best browsing experience possible. If you continue to use this website without changing your cookie settings or you click "Accept" below then you are consenting to this.

Close